900,000 New Yorkers Lost at Least 3 Loved Ones to Covid


Josefa Santana, 96, didn’t go away her Washington Heights house when New York City shut down to gradual the unfold of the coronavirus in March 2020. But her son, a butcher, had to work. He was the one one to go away the house in these weeks, so he most likely was the one who introduced the virus in.

Despite her household’s efforts to defend her, Ms. Santana bought sick, after which died. She was certainly one of three kinfolk whom her granddaughter, Lymarie Francisco, misplaced to Covid-19 within the first 12 months of the pandemic, Ms. Francisco mentioned final week.

The toll was devastating for her. It was additionally emblematic of the dimensions of loss and trauma in New York within the early levels of the pandemic, which new metropolis information, launched to The New York Times, exhibits in stark element.

An estimated two million New Yorkers — almost one in 4 — misplaced at least one particular person shut to them to Covid inside the first 16 months of the virus’s arrival, in accordance to the info, which was collected in mid-2021 by federal census staff on behalf of of town. Nearly 900,000 New Yorkers misplaced at least three individuals they mentioned they have been shut to, an open-ended class that included kinfolk and pals, the survey discovered.


Ms. Francisco, 36, misplaced an uncle about two months after her grandmother, and later, she additionally misplaced an aunt. But it was the lack of her grandmother, who raised her, that almost all impacts her to at the present time.

“I’m always interested by my grandmother,” she mentioned. “I’m going each different Sunday to the cemetery and simply sit there. And I simply spoke to her.”

The discovering concerning the scale of loss was amongst a number of from the survey, often known as the New York City Housing and Vacancy Survey, that shed new mild on the affect of the pandemic within the metropolis. The survey consisted of in-person interviews with a statistically consultant pattern of greater than 7,000 New York City households. While the first function of the survey, performed each three years, is to assess New Yorkers’ housing situations, questions on Covid have been added to the 2021 model.

Its findings echoed earlier research that documented how Black and Hispanic New Yorkers died from Covid at greater charges than white New Yorkers in 2020. In half, this was due to greater poverty ranges and fewer entry to high-quality medical care. But one other possible purpose was that individuals of coloration made up the majority of the important staff who reported to work through the metropolis’s preliminary 11-week shutdown, when all colleges and nonessential companies have been ordered to shut and folks urged to keep house, the survey discovered. .


About 1.1 million of town’s 8.4 million residents saved going to work between March and June 2020, the survey reported. Of these, about 800,000, or 72 %, have been individuals of coloration, a broad class that included all New Yorkers who didn’t establish as non-Hispanic and white.


The areas that have been hit hardest by Covid, together with southeast Brooklyn, the Bronx, Upper Manhattan and the southeast nook of Queens, had excessive numbers of important staff. The individuals who went to work delivered meals, staffed eating places, offered baby care and cleansing, or labored in well being care and transit.

Losing family members to the virus was extra widespread amongst these staff, particularly those that have been low-income and folks of coloration, the survey discovered. While a few quarter of all New Yorkers misplaced at least one particular person they have been shut to, a few third of low-income important staff who have been individuals of coloration did. Eleven % of all New Yorkers misplaced at least three individuals to Covid, in contrast with 16 % of low-income important staff, the survey discovered.

Janeth Solis, 52, of the Bronx, misplaced 4 family members through the first 12 months and a half of the pandemic. Her mom, step-grandmother and grandmother, who lived collectively in a home in Ridgewood, Queens, died one after the other within the pandemic’s first weeks. Her mother-in-law died in April 2021.

It wasn’t till this 12 months that Ms. Solis was in a position to go to her grandmother’s ashes, which had been shipped to her native Colombia in June 2020. The go to and remedy have helped her heal.


“We did not actually have closure,” she mentioned.

Rates of melancholy and nervousness in New York rose through the pandemic, significantly amongst those that had misplaced family members and people beneath monetary pressure. Based on analysis from previous disasters, these results are possible to proceed for months or years to come, researchers at the Department of Health have mentioned.

“Mental well being wants are on the rise in all places,” mentioned Dr. Ashwin Vasan, town’s well being commissioner. “And it is very troublesome to separate that from the affect of trauma and grief.”

By May 2021, about 33,000 New Yorkers had died from Covid-19, in accordance to a New York Times tracker. At least 6,000 New Yorkers have died since then.

Many New Yorkers are additionally linked to individuals who died elsewhere.

“So many people are shut to individuals exterior of the 5 boroughs, and out of doors of the nation,” mentioned Elyzabeth Gaumer, the chief analysis officer at the Department of Housing and Development.

Leave a Comment